Arabians Tonka
MontaleTop notes The opening
Bergamot
Saffron (on both lists)
Heart notes The middle
Rose (on both lists)
Oud
Base notes The dry-down
Amber
Oakmoss
Tonka bean (on both lists)
Leather
Brown sugar
White musk (on both lists)
Montale Amber woody


Looking for a Montale Arabians Tonka dupe? The Arabian perfume closest to Montale Arabians Tonka on paper is Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk. It shares the saffron, rose, tonka bean and musk, with a sugary note near the original's brown sugar; it lists no oud or leather, so it is the softer of the two.
Each perfume as its note pyramid: top, heart and base, as its house publishes them. A note ringed in vermilion is on Arabians Tonka's list and on an alternative's.
On both listsOn one list
Arabians Tonka opens on bergamot and saffron, sets rose against oud, and rests on amber, oakmoss, tonka bean, leather, brown sugar and white musk. Karus Secret Musk keeps the sweet centre of that: saffron, rose, tonka and musk, with sugar.
Karus Secret Musk leaves out the dark half of Arabians Tonka: no oud, leather, oakmoss or amber, and no bergamot. In their place it lists chocolate and red fruits, and it leads with the musk that Montale keeps for the base.


Pair 1 of 1
Four of Arabians Tonka's ten listed notes are also on Karus Secret Musk's list.
One column for each perfume, Arabians Tonka first. A lit note is on both lists, a dimmed one is on Arabians Tonka's list alone.
The originalArabians TonkaMontale | Arabian alternativeKarus Secret MuskKhadlaj | |
|---|---|---|
| 01Notes in common with Arabians Tonka | Ten listed notes
Every other column is read against these. | Four of ten of Arabians Tonka's listed notes
Not on its list bergamot, oud, amber, oakmoss, leather and brown sugar |
| 02Notes of its own | Six of its own
| Three of its own
|
| 03In one line | Character Amber woody: bergamot and saffron on top, amber and oakmoss beneath. | Where it differs Softer and sweeter: chocolate and red fruits; no oud, leather, oakmoss or amber. |
| 04When it suits | When it suits Arabians Tonka
Suits autumn and winter, evening. | |
| Seasons as rated in the Fragnatique app | ||
Two perfumes in one style. Which one depends on what you want from it.
Read side by side, the published note lists place Arabians Tonka and Karus Secret Musk in the same style. Neither replaces the other: each is its own perfume, made by a different house.

The original
It suits you if you want the composition the comparison starts from, as Montale made it. Arabians Tonka opens on bergamot and saffron, sets rose against oud, and rests on amber, oakmoss, tonka bean, leather, brown sugar and white musk.

Arabian alternative
It suits you if you want the saffron, rose and tonka bean of Arabians Tonka in a perfume by Khadlaj, with sugary notes, chocolate and red fruits of its own.
Where it differs Softer and sweeter: chocolate and red fruits; no oud, leather, oakmoss or amber.
A note list says which materials are present, not how much of each. Wear them on skin, one on each wrist, before you decide.
On published notes, Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk comes closest: it shares the saffron, rose, tonka bean and musk. It is a softer perfume, without the oud and leather, so wear one on each wrist for a day before you choose.
Khadlaj Karus Secret Musk shares its saffron, rose, tonka and musk. Expect chocolate and red fruits where Arabians Tonka has oud and leather.
Bergamot and saffron over rose and oud, on amber, oakmoss, tonka bean, leather, brown sugar and white musk, as Montale lists it.