Good Girl
Carolina HerreraTop notes The opening
Almond (on both lists)
Heart notes The middle
Jasmine sambac (on both lists)
Tuberose (on both lists)
Base notes The dry-down
Tonka bean (on both lists)
Cocoa (on both lists)
Carolina Herrera Ambery floral


Qimmah for Women
Miss Armaf Attitude
The Pride of Armaf Pour FemmeLooking for a Good Girl dupe? The Arabian alternatives often named for Carolina Herrera Good Girl are Lattafa Qimmah for Women and Armaf Miss Armaf Attitude. Qimmah lists every Good Girl note, almond, jasmine, tuberose, tonka and cocoa, and adds coffee and vanilla; Armaf The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme shares four of the five, without the tuberose.
Each perfume as its note pyramid: top, heart and base, as its house publishes them. A note ringed in vermilion is on Good Girl's list and on an alternative's.
On both listsOn one list
Arabian alternativeGood Girl, created by Louise Turner in 2016, sets almond and white flowers, jasmine sambac and tuberose, over tonka and cocoa. Qimmah repeats that whole outline; Attitude keeps the almond, jasmine, tuberose and tonka, and The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme the almond, jasmine, tonka and cocoa.
All three add coffee, which Carolina Herrera's list for the eau de parfum does not name. Qimmah and Attitude also add vanilla; Qimmah puts sandalwood in the base, Attitude has no cocoa and adds rose, narcissus, amber and cedar, and The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme trades the tuberose for mandarin, orange blossom and patchouli.


Qimmah for WomenPair 1 of 3
All five of Good Girl's listed notes are also on Qimmah for Women's list.
Nothing. Every note is shared.


Miss Armaf AttitudePair 2 of 3
Four of Good Girl's five listed notes are also on Miss Armaf Attitude's list.


The Pride of Armaf Pour FemmePair 3 of 3
Four of Good Girl's five listed notes are also on The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme's list.
One column for each perfume, Good Girl first. A lit note is on both lists, a dimmed one is on Good Girl's list alone.
The originalGood GirlCarolina Herrera | Arabian alternativeQimmah for Women Lattafa | Arabian alternativeMiss Armaf Attitude Armaf | Arabian alternativeThe Pride of Armaf Pour Femme Armaf | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01Notes in common with Good Girl | Five listed notes
Every other column is read against these. | Five of five of Good Girl's listed notes
All five are on its list. | Four of five of Good Girl's listed notes
Not on its list cocoa | Four of five of Good Girl's listed notes
Not on its list tuberose |
| 02Notes of its own | None of its own Each of its notes is on an alternative's list too. | Three of its own
| Nine of its own
| Four of its own
|
| 03In one line | Character Ambery floral: almond on top, tonka bean and cocoa beneath. | Where it differs Coffee on top and vanilla and sandalwood in the base. | Where it differs No cocoa; rose, narcissus, amber and cedar make it more floral and woody. | Where it differs No tuberose; mandarin and orange blossom on top, coffee in the heart and patchouli in the base. |
| 04When it suits | When it suits Good Girl
Suits spring, autumn and winter, day and evening. | |||
| Seasons as rated in the Fragnatique app | ||||
Four perfumes in one style. Which one depends on what you want from it.
Read side by side, the published note lists place Good Girl, Qimmah for Women, Miss Armaf Attitude and The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme in the same style. None of them replaces another: each is its own perfume, made by a different house.

The original
It suits you if you want the composition the comparison starts from, as Carolina Herrera made it. Good Girl, created by Louise Turner in 2016, sets almond and white flowers, jasmine sambac and tuberose, over tonka and cocoa.

Arabian alternative
It suits you if you want the almond, jasmine sambac and tuberose of Good Girl in a perfume by Lattafa, with coffee, vanilla and sandalwood of its own.
Where it differs Coffee on top and vanilla and sandalwood in the base.

Arabian alternative
It suits you if you want the almond, jasmine sambac and tuberose of Good Girl in a perfume by Armaf, with rose, bergamot and orange blossom of its own.
Where it differs No cocoa; rose, narcissus, amber and cedar make it more floral and woody.

Arabian alternative
It suits you if you want the almond, jasmine sambac and tonka bean of Good Girl in a perfume by Armaf, with mandarin, orange blossom and coffee of its own.
Where it differs No tuberose; mandarin and orange blossom on top, coffee in the heart and patchouli in the base.
A note list says which materials are present, not how much of each. Wear them on skin, one on each wrist, before you decide.
The Arabian alternatives often named for Carolina Herrera Good Girl are Lattafa Qimmah for Women and Armaf Miss Armaf Attitude. Qimmah lists every Good Girl note, almond, jasmine, tuberose, tonka and cocoa, and adds coffee and vanilla; Armaf The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme shares four of the five, without the tuberose.
Lattafa Qimmah for Women is the closest on paper: its list holds almond, jasmine, tuberose, tonka and cocoa, every note Carolina Herrera names, plus coffee, vanilla and sandalwood. Armaf Miss Armaf Attitude keeps the almond, jasmine, tuberose and tonka, without cocoa, and Armaf The Pride of Armaf Pour Femme the almond, jasmine, tonka and cocoa, without tuberose.
Carolina Herrera's own list for the eau de parfum names almond, jasmine sambac, tuberose, tonka bean and cocoa, not coffee. All three Arabian alternatives here list coffee.