Vanilla 28
KayaliTop notes The opening
Vanilla (on both lists)
Jasmine (on both lists)
Heart notes The middle
Tonka bean (on both lists)
Base notes The dry-down
Brown sugar
Amberwood (on both lists)
Musk (on both lists)
Patchouli
Kayali Amber vanilla

Vanilla 28

KhamrahLooking for a Kayali Vanilla 28 dupe? The two Arabian perfumes closest to Kayali Vanilla 28 on paper are Paris Corner Eshal Vanilla and Lattafa Khamrah. Eshal Vanilla keeps the vanilla, jasmine and musk and sweetens them with caramel; Khamrah shares the vanilla, tonka and amber woods inside a spiced date accord.
Each perfume as its note pyramid: top, heart and base, as its house publishes them. A note ringed in vermilion is on Vanilla 28's list and on an alternative's.
On both listsOn one list
Arabian alternativeVanilla 28 opens on Madagascan vanilla orchid and creamy jasmine, holds tonka at its heart and rests on brown sugar, amber woods, musk and patchouli. Eshal Vanilla follows the sweet, floral side of that outline; Khamrah follows the warm, woody side.
Eshal Vanilla has no tonka, amber woods or patchouli: rose joins the jasmine and caramel stands where the brown sugar was. Khamrah has no jasmine or musk and travels further, with bergamot, cinnamon and nutmeg on top, dates and praline in the heart, benzoin and myrrh below.

Vanilla 28
Pair 1 of 2
Three of Vanilla 28's seven listed notes are also on Eshal Vanilla's list.

Vanilla 28
KhamrahPair 2 of 2
Three of Vanilla 28's seven listed notes are also on Khamrah's list.
One column for each perfume, Vanilla 28 first. A lit note is on both lists, a dimmed one is on Vanilla 28's list alone.
The originalVanilla 28 Kayali | Arabian alternativeEshal VanillaParis Corner | Arabian alternativeKhamrah Lattafa | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 01Notes in common with Vanilla 28 | Seven listed notes
Every other column is read against these. | Three of seven of Vanilla 28's listed notes
Not on its list tonka bean, brown sugar, amberwood and patchouli | Three of seven of Vanilla 28's listed notes
Not on its list jasmine, brown sugar, musk and patchouli |
| 02Notes of its own | Two of its own
| Three of its own
| Ten of its own
|
| 03In one line | Character Amber vanilla: vanilla and jasmine on top, brown sugar and amberwood beneath. | Where it differs Rose in the heart and caramel in the base; no tonka, amber woods or patchouli. | Where it differs A spiced date style, with cinnamon, nutmeg, praline, benzoin and myrrh; no jasmine or musk. |
| 04When it suits | When it suits Vanilla 28
Suits autumn and winter, evening. | When it suits Khamrah
Suits autumn and winter, day and evening. | |
| Seasons as rated in the Fragnatique app | |||
Three perfumes in one style. Which one depends on what you want from it.
Read side by side, the published note lists place Vanilla 28, Eshal Vanilla and Khamrah in the same style. None of them replaces another: each is its own perfume, made by a different house.

The original
It suits you if you want the composition the comparison starts from, as Kayali made it. Vanilla 28 opens on Madagascan vanilla orchid and creamy jasmine, holds tonka at its heart and rests on brown sugar, amber woods, musk and patchouli.

Arabian alternative
It suits you if you want the vanilla, jasmine and musk of Vanilla 28 in a perfume by Paris Corner, with sugary notes, rose and caramel of its own.
Where it differs Rose in the heart and caramel in the base; no tonka, amber woods or patchouli.

Arabian alternative
It suits you if you want the vanilla, tonka bean and amberwood of Vanilla 28 in a perfume by Lattafa, with bergamot, cinnamon and nutmeg of its own.
Where it differs A spiced date style, with cinnamon, nutmeg, praline, benzoin and myrrh; no jasmine or musk.
A note list says which materials are present, not how much of each. Wear them on skin, one on each wrist, before you decide.
On published notes, Paris Corner Eshal Vanilla comes closest: vanilla, jasmine and musk under a sugary opening. Lattafa Khamrah shares the vanilla, tonka and amber woods in a spicier style. Each is its own perfume, so wear one on each wrist for a day before you choose.
Paris Corner Eshal Vanilla and Lattafa Khamrah. Eshal Vanilla is the sweeter, more floral of the two; Khamrah is darker, with dates and spice.
Vanilla orchid and jasmine over tonka, on a base of brown sugar, amber woods, musk and patchouli, as Kayali describes it.