Skip to content

Creed Fresh citrus

Silver Mountain Water Dupes: Arabian perfumes that smell like Creed Silver Mountain Water

The original
Silver Mountain Water by Creed, bottle
CreedSilver Mountain Water
Arabian alternatives
Supremacy in Heaven by Afnan, bottle
Supremacy in Heaven
Club de Nuit Sillage by Armaf, bottle
Club de Nuit Sillage
On both lists green tea, bergamot, black currant budBottles shown at one height, not to scale.

Looking for a Silver Mountain Water dupe? The Arabian alternatives often named for Creed Silver Mountain Water are Afnan Supremacy in Heaven and Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage. Supremacy in Heaven shares its bergamot, mandarin, green tea, blackcurrant, musk and sandalwood; Club de Nuit Sillage keeps the bergamot, blackcurrant, sandalwood and musk with more citrus and flowers.

01 Scent family
Fresh citrus
02 Supremacy in Heaven
Six of seven of Silver Mountain Water's listed notes are on its list too
03 Club de Nuit Sillage
Four of seven of Silver Mountain Water's listed notes are on its list too

Which notes does Silver Mountain Water share with Supremacy in Heaven and Club de Nuit Sillage?

Each perfume as its note pyramid: top, heart and base, as its house publishes them. A note ringed in vermilion is on Silver Mountain Water's list and on an alternative's.

On both listsOn one list

Silver Mountain Water by Creed, bottleThe original

Silver Mountain Water

Creed

Top notes The opening

  • Bergamot, perfume noteBergamot (on both lists)
  • Mandarin, perfume noteMandarin (on both lists)
  • Neroli, perfume noteNeroli

Heart notes The middle

  • Green tea, perfume noteGreen tea (on both lists)
  • Black currant bud, perfume noteBlack currant bud (on both lists)

Base notes The dry-down

  • Sandalwood, perfume noteSandalwood (on both lists)
  • Musk, perfume noteMusk (on both lists)
Supremacy in Heaven by Afnan, bottleArabian alternative

Supremacy in Heaven

Afnan

Top notes The opening

  • Bergamot, perfume noteBergamot (on both lists)
  • Mandarin, perfume noteMandarin (on both lists)

Heart notes The middle

  • Green tea, perfume noteGreen tea (on both lists)
  • Black currant, perfume noteBlack currant (on both lists)

Base notes The dry-down

  • Musk, perfume noteMusk (on both lists)
  • Sandalwood, perfume noteSandalwood (on both lists)
  • Woody notes, perfume noteWoody notes
Club de Nuit Sillage by Armaf, bottleArabian alternative

Club de Nuit Sillage

Armaf

Top notes The opening

  • Bergamot, perfume noteBergamot (on both lists)
  • Lemon, perfume noteLemon
  • Lime, perfume noteLime
  • Ginger, perfume noteGinger
  • Black currant, perfume noteBlack currant (on both lists)
  • Violet leaves, perfume noteViolet leaves

Heart notes The middle

  • Jasmine, perfume noteJasmine
  • Iris, perfume noteIris
  • Rose, perfume noteRose

Base notes The dry-down

  • Sandalwood, perfume noteSandalwood (on both lists)
  • Cedarwood, perfume noteCedarwood
  • Musk, perfume noteMusk (on both lists)
  • Ambroxan, perfume noteAmbroxan

Where is each alternative like Silver Mountain Water, and where does it differ?

Alike

Silver Mountain Water is cool and clean: bergamot and mandarin over green tea and blackcurrant bud, with a soft sandalwood and musk base. Supremacy in Heaven follows that outline almost line by line.

Different

Supremacy in Heaven adds unnamed woods to the base and lists no neroli. Club de Nuit Sillage adds lemon, lime, ginger, violet leaf, jasmine, iris and rose, with cedarwood and ambroxan; reviewers find its dry-down less icy.

The original
Silver Mountain Water by Creed, bottle
CreedSilver Mountain Water
The alternative
Supremacy in Heaven by Afnan, bottle
Supremacy in Heaven
Silver Mountain Water by Creed beside Supremacy in Heaven by Afnan, with the notes they share: green tea, bergamot, black currant bud.

Pair 1 of 2

Silver Mountain Water vs Afnan Supremacy in Heaven

Six of Silver Mountain Water's seven listed notes are also on Supremacy in Heaven's list.

Silver Mountain Water only

  • Neroli, perfume noteNeroli

On both lists

  • Bergamot, perfume noteBergamot (on both lists)
  • Mandarin, perfume noteMandarin (on both lists)
  • Green tea, perfume noteGreen tea (on both lists)
  • Black currant bud, perfume noteBlack currant bud (on both lists)
  • Sandalwood, perfume noteSandalwood (on both lists)
  • Musk, perfume noteMusk (on both lists)

Supremacy in Heaven only

  • Woody notes, perfume noteWoody notes
Why they are compared
Its list follows Silver Mountain Water almost line by line: bergamot and mandarin, green tea and blackcurrant, musk and sandalwood.
Where it differs
No neroli; plain woods in the base.
The original
Silver Mountain Water by Creed, bottle
CreedSilver Mountain Water
The alternative
Club de Nuit Sillage by Armaf, bottle
Club de Nuit Sillage
Silver Mountain Water by Creed beside Club de Nuit Sillage by Armaf, with the notes they share: bergamot, black currant bud, sandalwood.

Pair 2 of 2

Silver Mountain Water vs Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage

Four of Silver Mountain Water's seven listed notes are also on Club de Nuit Sillage's list.

Silver Mountain Water only

  • Mandarin, perfume noteMandarin
  • Neroli, perfume noteNeroli
  • Green tea, perfume noteGreen tea

On both lists

  • Bergamot, perfume noteBergamot (on both lists)
  • Black currant bud, perfume noteBlack currant bud (on both lists)
  • Sandalwood, perfume noteSandalwood (on both lists)
  • Musk, perfume noteMusk (on both lists)

Club de Nuit Sillage only

  • Lemon, perfume noteLemon
  • Lime, perfume noteLime
  • Ginger, perfume noteGinger
  • Violet leaves, perfume noteViolet leaves
  • Jasmine, perfume noteJasmine
  • Iris, perfume noteIris
  • Rose, perfume noteRose
  • Cedarwood, perfume noteCedarwood
  • Ambroxan, perfume noteAmbroxan
Why they are compared
Often named one of the closest takes on Silver Mountain Water; it shares the bergamot, blackcurrant, sandalwood and musk.
Where it differs
More citrus and flowers; no green tea, and a warmer ambroxan base.

How do the Silver Mountain Water dupes compare at a glance?

One column for each perfume, Silver Mountain Water first. A lit note is on both lists, a dimmed one is on Silver Mountain Water's list alone.

Creed Silver Mountain Water, Afnan Supremacy in Heaven and Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage compared: notes in common with Silver Mountain Water, notes of its own, in one line and when it suits.
Silver Mountain Water by Creed, bottleThe originalSilver Mountain WaterCreedSupremacy in Heaven by Afnan, bottleArabian alternativeSupremacy in HeavenClub de Nuit Sillage by Armaf, bottleArabian alternativeClub de Nuit Sillage
01Notes in common with Silver Mountain Water

Seven listed notes

  • Bergamot
  • Mandarin
  • Neroli
  • Green tea
  • Black currant bud
  • Sandalwood
  • Musk

Every other column is read against these.

Six of seven of Silver Mountain Water's listed notes

  • Bergamot (on both lists)
  • Mandarin (on both lists)
  • Neroli (not on its list)
  • Green tea (on both lists)
  • Black currant bud (on both lists)
  • Sandalwood (on both lists)
  • Musk (on both lists)

Not on its list neroli

Four of seven of Silver Mountain Water's listed notes

  • Bergamot (on both lists)
  • Mandarin (not on its list)
  • Neroli (not on its list)
  • Green tea (not on its list)
  • Black currant bud (on both lists)
  • Sandalwood (on both lists)
  • Musk (on both lists)

Not on its list mandarin, neroli and green tea

02Notes of its own

One of its own

  • Neroli

One of its own

  • Woody notes

Nine of its own

  • Lemon
  • Lime
  • Ginger
  • Violet leaves
  • Jasmine
  • Iris
  • Rose
  • Cedarwood
  • Ambroxan
03In one line

Character

Fresh citrus: bergamot and mandarin on top, sandalwood and musk beneath.

Where it differs

No neroli; plain woods in the base.

Where it differs

More citrus and flowers; no green tea, and a warmer ambroxan base.

04When it suits

When it suits

Silver Mountain Water

  • Spring: suits
  • Summer: suits
  • Autumn: not named
  • Winter: not named
  • Day: suits
  • Evening: suits

Suits spring and summer, day and evening.

When it suits

Club de Nuit Sillage

  • Spring: suits
  • Summer: suits
  • Autumn: suits
  • Winter: not named
  • Day: suits
  • Evening: suits

Suits spring, summer and autumn, day and evening.

Seasons as rated in the Fragnatique app

Silver Mountain Water, Supremacy in Heaven or Club de Nuit Sillage: which one suits you?

Three perfumes in one style. Which one depends on what you want from it.

Read side by side, the published note lists place Silver Mountain Water, Supremacy in Heaven and Club de Nuit Sillage in the same style. None of them replaces another: each is its own perfume, made by a different house.

  • Silver Mountain Water by Creed, bottle

    The original

    Creed Silver Mountain Water

    It suits you if you want the composition the comparison starts from, as Creed made it. Silver Mountain Water is cool and clean: bergamot and mandarin over green tea and blackcurrant bud, with a soft sandalwood and musk base.

  • Supremacy in Heaven by Afnan, bottle

    Arabian alternative

    Afnan Supremacy in Heaven

    It suits you if you want the bergamot, mandarin and green tea of Silver Mountain Water in a perfume by Afnan, with woody notes of its own.

    Where it differs No neroli; plain woods in the base.

  • Club de Nuit Sillage by Armaf, bottle

    Arabian alternative

    Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage

    It suits you if you want the bergamot, black currant bud and sandalwood of Silver Mountain Water in a perfume by Armaf, with lemon, lime and ginger of its own.

    Where it differs More citrus and flowers; no green tea, and a warmer ambroxan base.

A note list says which materials are present, not how much of each. Wear them on skin, one on each wrist, before you decide.

Your own match

Start from the perfumes you already love.

Tell Fragnatique which perfumes you wear and it suggests what to try next, using Fragnatique's proprietary algorithm. Free on the App Store.

Download on the App Store

Silver Mountain Water dupes: short answers

What smells like Silver Mountain Water?

The Arabian alternatives often named for Creed Silver Mountain Water are Afnan Supremacy in Heaven and Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage. Supremacy in Heaven shares its bergamot, mandarin, green tea, blackcurrant, musk and sandalwood; Club de Nuit Sillage keeps the bergamot, blackcurrant, sandalwood and musk with more citrus and flowers.

What is the best Silver Mountain Water dupe?

Afnan Supremacy in Heaven is the closest on paper: Afnan lists bergamot and mandarin, green tea and blackcurrant, then musk, sandalwood and woods. Armaf Club de Nuit Sillage is the brighter, more floral option.

What does Silver Mountain Water smell like?

Cold, clean citrus and green tea over a soft blackcurrant and musk base. Reviewers often call it icy or mineral.